{ "schema": "KLT-MATDES-ARBD-CHEM-CP1-v1", "adapter_version": "0.1.0", "annotations_hash": "1a9776b9d0b2c81b2eb7d364395c4f4739d76fb1171262e09379150ce675799d", "upstream_engine": "ARBD Build 28 Python core, unchanged", "model": { "authors": [ { "author_id": "KURPISHEV-IB", "display_name": "Курпишев Иван Борисович" } ], "work_families": [ { "work_family_id": "KLT-TOME-VI-CHEMISTRY", "author_id": "KURPISHEV-IB" } ], "works": [ { "work_id": "T6-RU-INTEGRATED-1.1", "work_family_id": "KLT-TOME-VI-CHEMISTRY", "title": "Том VI. Химия KLT-RBD. Интегрированная редакция v1.1", "author_id": "KURPISHEV-IB", "relation": "EDITION", "publication_year": 2026, "language": "RU", "source_file": "T6_RU_INTEGRATED_v1_1.docx", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "public_url": "https://kurpishev.com/", "source_authority": "AUTHOR_PROJECT_ARCHIVE", "carrier_format": "DOCX_BODY_PARAGRAPHS_V1" } ], "occurrences": [ { "occurrence_id": "CHEM-OCC-P0012", "work_id": "T6-RU-INTEGRATED-1.1", "paragraph_index": 12, "quote": "Редакция v1.1 сохраняет полный корпус v0.10 и добавляет аудит целостности, закрывающие формальные патчи, русский proof/dependency-ledger 92/92 и вычислительную программу KLT-MATDES v0.6. Редакционная, формальная и программная целостность проверяются раздельно от эмпирического статуса. Внутренние mechanics-only fixtures и программные тесты не повышают статус DHC_chem; отсутствие независимого EXT-RUN и реального source-bound корпуса сохраняет ABSTAIN.", "claim_type": "CLAIM", "topic": "PROGRAM_STATUS", "evidence_role": "SCOPE_BOUNDARY", "attribution_status": "UNKNOWN", "review_required": true, "interpretation_review": "OPEN", "author_id": "KURPISHEV-IB", "work_family_id": "KLT-TOME-VI-CHEMISTRY", "locator": "word/document.xml body/p[13] (one-based)", "quote_semantics": "SOURCE_TRANSCRIPTION", "source_verified": true, "source_status": "DOCX_PARAGRAPH_VERIFIED", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "paragraph_hash": "80108d4741a0ebafa8be872f54c1a930f73a74774e7208aa1b294b9c583e75a5", "D": { "scope": "TEXTUAL_CARRIER_ONLY", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "paragraph_index": 12 }, "R": { "kind": "TEXTUAL_OCCURRENCE" }, "I": null, "U": null, "Dom": { "declared_keys": [ "CHEMISTRY_METHOD_PROTOCOL" ], "review_status": "OPEN" }, "domain_annotation_review": "OPEN", "truth_layer_promotion": 0, "proposed_domain_keys": [ "CHEMISTRY_METHOD_PROTOCOL" ], "domain_keys": [] }, { "occurrence_id": "CHEM-OCC-P0013", "work_id": "T6-RU-INTEGRATED-1.1", "paragraph_index": 13, "quote": "Статусный замок v1.1: EDITORIAL_INTEGRATION=PASS; software_tests=29/29 PASS; science=ABSTAIN; DHC_chem=OPEN-NOT-CONFIRMED; EXT-RUN=NOT_RUN; truth_layer_promotion=0; T6-RA5=NOT_ISSUED.", "claim_type": "CLAIM", "topic": "PROGRAM_STATUS", "evidence_role": "SCOPE_BOUNDARY", "attribution_status": "UNKNOWN", "review_required": true, "interpretation_review": "OPEN", "author_id": "KURPISHEV-IB", "work_family_id": "KLT-TOME-VI-CHEMISTRY", "locator": "word/document.xml body/p[14] (one-based)", "quote_semantics": "SOURCE_TRANSCRIPTION", "source_verified": true, "source_status": "DOCX_PARAGRAPH_VERIFIED", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "paragraph_hash": "db0fe521c62e0010e10df05919cb5fdb17dd07e45417e8f50b0eeb9e811b2c84", "D": { "scope": "TEXTUAL_CARRIER_ONLY", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "paragraph_index": 13 }, "R": { "kind": "TEXTUAL_OCCURRENCE" }, "I": null, "U": null, "Dom": { "declared_keys": [ "CHEMISTRY_METHOD_PROTOCOL" ], "review_status": "OPEN" }, "domain_annotation_review": "OPEN", "truth_layer_promotion": 0, "proposed_domain_keys": [ "CHEMISTRY_METHOD_PROTOCOL" ], "domain_keys": [] }, { "occurrence_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1584", "work_id": "T6-RU-INTEGRATED-1.1", "paragraph_index": 1584, "quote": "Утверждение. Восемь химических строк-реперов v2.1 не утверждаются автоматически как полные Rep_chem.", "claim_type": "CLAIM", "topic": "REPER_REPRESENTATION", "evidence_role": "SCOPE_BOUNDARY", "attribution_status": "UNKNOWN", "review_required": true, "interpretation_review": "OPEN", "author_id": "KURPISHEV-IB", "work_family_id": "KLT-TOME-VI-CHEMISTRY", "locator": "word/document.xml body/p[1585] (one-based)", "quote_semantics": "SOURCE_TRANSCRIPTION", "source_verified": true, "source_status": "DOCX_PARAGRAPH_VERIFIED", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "paragraph_hash": "fed7982ded52eaaf7db4fc728d8656ce88ebc45ae62777472af32b5ae1539c34", "D": { "scope": "TEXTUAL_CARRIER_ONLY", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "paragraph_index": 1584 }, "R": { "kind": "TEXTUAL_OCCURRENCE" }, "I": null, "U": null, "Dom": { "declared_keys": [ "CHEMISTRY_METHOD_PROTOCOL" ], "review_status": "OPEN" }, "domain_annotation_review": "OPEN", "truth_layer_promotion": 0, "proposed_domain_keys": [ "CHEMISTRY_METHOD_PROTOCOL" ], "domain_keys": [] }, { "occurrence_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1585", "work_id": "T6-RU-INTEGRATED-1.1", "paragraph_index": 1585, "quote": "Доказательство/основание. Они хранятся как legacy_import_rows с каноническим JSON, хешем строки и STAGED_ABSTAIN; из текстовых U/I/R/D не создаются reper_roles.", "claim_type": "CLAIM", "topic": "REPER_REPRESENTATION", "evidence_role": "SCOPE_BOUNDARY", "attribution_status": "UNKNOWN", "review_required": true, "interpretation_review": "OPEN", "author_id": "KURPISHEV-IB", "work_family_id": "KLT-TOME-VI-CHEMISTRY", "locator": "word/document.xml body/p[1586] (one-based)", "quote_semantics": "SOURCE_TRANSCRIPTION", "source_verified": true, "source_status": "DOCX_PARAGRAPH_VERIFIED", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "paragraph_hash": "a2c21bed1974abb119c8c2d53e7839341eb37925047bf65d577e86e3d3ac016b", "D": { "scope": "TEXTUAL_CARRIER_ONLY", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "paragraph_index": 1585 }, "R": { "kind": "TEXTUAL_OCCURRENCE" }, "I": null, "U": null, "Dom": { "declared_keys": [ "CHEMISTRY_METHOD_PROTOCOL" ], "review_status": "OPEN" }, "domain_annotation_review": "OPEN", "truth_layer_promotion": 0, "proposed_domain_keys": [ "CHEMISTRY_METHOD_PROTOCOL" ], "domain_keys": [] }, { "occurrence_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1590", "work_id": "T6-RU-INTEGRATED-1.1", "paragraph_index": 1590, "quote": "Утверждение. Протокол с неразрешённым жёстким gate представление v_protocol_decision возвращает как ABSTAIN.", "claim_type": "CLAIM", "topic": "READINESS_GATE", "evidence_role": "SUPPORT", "attribution_status": "UNKNOWN", "review_required": true, "interpretation_review": "OPEN", "author_id": "KURPISHEV-IB", "work_family_id": "KLT-TOME-VI-CHEMISTRY", "locator": "word/document.xml body/p[1591] (one-based)", "quote_semantics": "SOURCE_TRANSCRIPTION", "source_verified": true, "source_status": "DOCX_PARAGRAPH_VERIFIED", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "paragraph_hash": "99c7acdef3954d03bd624ade94480332aa26ee1203da3164edfb3c5fc4ab75f6", "D": { "scope": "TEXTUAL_CARRIER_ONLY", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "paragraph_index": 1590 }, "R": { "kind": "TEXTUAL_OCCURRENCE" }, "I": null, "U": null, "Dom": { "declared_keys": [ "CHEMISTRY_METHOD_PROTOCOL" ], "review_status": "OPEN" }, "domain_annotation_review": "OPEN", "truth_layer_promotion": 0, "proposed_domain_keys": [ "CHEMISTRY_METHOD_PROTOCOL" ], "domain_keys": [] }, { "occurrence_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1591", "work_id": "T6-RU-INTEGRATED-1.1", "paragraph_index": 1591, "quote": "Доказательство/основание. Представление считает жёсткие FAIL, UNKNOWN и NOT_RUN; положительное число выбирает ABSTAIN раньше любой ветви статуса кандидата.", "claim_type": "CLAIM", "topic": "READINESS_GATE", "evidence_role": "SUPPORT", "attribution_status": "UNKNOWN", "review_required": true, "interpretation_review": "OPEN", "author_id": "KURPISHEV-IB", "work_family_id": "KLT-TOME-VI-CHEMISTRY", "locator": "word/document.xml body/p[1592] (one-based)", "quote_semantics": "SOURCE_TRANSCRIPTION", "source_verified": true, "source_status": "DOCX_PARAGRAPH_VERIFIED", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "paragraph_hash": "bf8ada9208357952ecc52a27c4148cfee093bd048cb8d638f85245b71c2d501d", "D": { "scope": "TEXTUAL_CARRIER_ONLY", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "paragraph_index": 1591 }, "R": { "kind": "TEXTUAL_OCCURRENCE" }, "I": null, "U": null, "Dom": { "declared_keys": [ "CHEMISTRY_METHOD_PROTOCOL" ], "review_status": "OPEN" }, "domain_annotation_review": "OPEN", "truth_layer_promotion": 0, "proposed_domain_keys": [ "CHEMISTRY_METHOD_PROTOCOL" ], "domain_keys": [] }, { "occurrence_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1724", "work_id": "T6-RU-INTEGRATED-1.1", "paragraph_index": 1724, "quote": "Утверждение. Из одного химического C@C без внешней структуры нельзя единственным образом получить Rep_chem с релевантными I,U,D_rep и Dom.", "claim_type": "CLAIM", "topic": "STRUCTURE_BINDING", "evidence_role": "SCOPE_BOUNDARY", "attribution_status": "UNKNOWN", "review_required": true, "interpretation_review": "OPEN", "author_id": "KURPISHEV-IB", "work_family_id": "KLT-TOME-VI-CHEMISTRY", "locator": "word/document.xml body/p[1725] (one-based)", "quote_semantics": "SOURCE_TRANSCRIPTION", "source_verified": true, "source_status": "DOCX_PARAGRAPH_VERIFIED", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "paragraph_hash": "783a4d4481e316269e9c10f77afbe098a3a2be2965f865e00d848af080f31c89", "D": { "scope": "TEXTUAL_CARRIER_ONLY", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "paragraph_index": 1724 }, "R": { "kind": "TEXTUAL_OCCURRENCE" }, "I": null, "U": null, "Dom": { "declared_keys": [ "CHEMISTRY_METHOD_PROTOCOL" ], "review_status": "OPEN" }, "domain_annotation_review": "OPEN", "truth_layer_promotion": 0, "proposed_domain_keys": [ "CHEMISTRY_METHOD_PROTOCOL" ], "domain_keys": [] }, { "occurrence_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1725", "work_id": "T6-RU-INTEGRATED-1.1", "paragraph_index": 1725, "quote": "Доказательство/основание. Фиксированная пара событие@граница допускает разные исследовательские инварианты I, разные классы альтернатив U и разные виды основания D_rep. Ни одна координата C@C не выбирает их единственно. Следовательно, требуется зарегистрированный оператор выбора J.", "claim_type": "CLAIM", "topic": "STRUCTURE_BINDING", "evidence_role": "SCOPE_BOUNDARY", "attribution_status": "UNKNOWN", "review_required": true, "interpretation_review": "OPEN", "author_id": "KURPISHEV-IB", "work_family_id": "KLT-TOME-VI-CHEMISTRY", "locator": "word/document.xml body/p[1726] (one-based)", "quote_semantics": "SOURCE_TRANSCRIPTION", "source_verified": true, "source_status": "DOCX_PARAGRAPH_VERIFIED", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "paragraph_hash": "4c0d620e0f7a5dbb8a76f3c5ebb6e41977e2929d702c9eb7277ae17140b4c739", "D": { "scope": "TEXTUAL_CARRIER_ONLY", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "paragraph_index": 1725 }, "R": { "kind": "TEXTUAL_OCCURRENCE" }, "I": null, "U": null, "Dom": { "declared_keys": [ "CHEMISTRY_METHOD_PROTOCOL" ], "review_status": "OPEN" }, "domain_annotation_review": "OPEN", "truth_layer_promotion": 0, "proposed_domain_keys": [ "CHEMISTRY_METHOD_PROTOCOL" ], "domain_keys": [] }, { "occurrence_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1744", "work_id": "T6-RU-INTEGRATED-1.1", "paragraph_index": 1744, "quote": "Утверждение. В конечной композиции Safe-операторов любой промежуточный ABSTAIN исключает финальный Ok.", "claim_type": "CLAIM", "topic": "SAFE_COMPOSITION", "evidence_role": "SUPPORT", "attribution_status": "UNKNOWN", "review_required": true, "interpretation_review": "OPEN", "author_id": "KURPISHEV-IB", "work_family_id": "KLT-TOME-VI-CHEMISTRY", "locator": "word/document.xml body/p[1745] (one-based)", "quote_semantics": "SOURCE_TRANSCRIPTION", "source_verified": true, "source_status": "DOCX_PARAGRAPH_VERIFIED", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "paragraph_hash": "f7d7a3a6db09e218ffb57b178ff336ed40c39b4b8e7c493902f249d208805ecb", "D": { "scope": "TEXTUAL_CARRIER_ONLY", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "paragraph_index": 1744 }, "R": { "kind": "TEXTUAL_OCCURRENCE" }, "I": null, "U": null, "Dom": { "declared_keys": [ "CHEMISTRY_METHOD_PROTOCOL" ], "review_status": "OPEN" }, "domain_annotation_review": "OPEN", "truth_layer_promotion": 0, "proposed_domain_keys": [ "CHEMISTRY_METHOD_PROTOCOL" ], "domain_keys": [] }, { "occurrence_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1745", "work_id": "T6-RU-INTEGRATED-1.1", "paragraph_index": 1745, "quote": "Доказательство/основание. Определим bind так, что ABSTAIN(B) передаётся без вычисления следующего шага, а два набора blockers объединяются. Индукция по длине цепочки показывает: после первого ABSTAIN все последующие результаты остаются ABSTAIN.", "claim_type": "CLAIM", "topic": "SAFE_COMPOSITION", "evidence_role": "SUPPORT", "attribution_status": "UNKNOWN", "review_required": true, "interpretation_review": "OPEN", "author_id": "KURPISHEV-IB", "work_family_id": "KLT-TOME-VI-CHEMISTRY", "locator": "word/document.xml body/p[1746] (one-based)", "quote_semantics": "SOURCE_TRANSCRIPTION", "source_verified": true, "source_status": "DOCX_PARAGRAPH_VERIFIED", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "paragraph_hash": "531839135ddaef8e5c7b14d7e2a70922367b05420832cb7326fa67cfac36d332", "D": { "scope": "TEXTUAL_CARRIER_ONLY", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "paragraph_index": 1745 }, "R": { "kind": "TEXTUAL_OCCURRENCE" }, "I": null, "U": null, "Dom": { "declared_keys": [ "CHEMISTRY_METHOD_PROTOCOL" ], "review_status": "OPEN" }, "domain_annotation_review": "OPEN", "truth_layer_promotion": 0, "proposed_domain_keys": [ "CHEMISTRY_METHOD_PROTOCOL" ], "domain_keys": [] }, { "occurrence_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1814", "work_id": "T6-RU-INTEGRATED-1.1", "paragraph_index": 1814, "quote": "Утверждение. При G_EXT=NOT_RUN статусный морфизм v0.8 возвращает ABSTAIN независимо от величины эффекта fixture.", "claim_type": "CLAIM", "topic": "EXTERNAL_VALIDATION", "evidence_role": "SCOPE_BOUNDARY", "attribution_status": "UNKNOWN", "review_required": true, "interpretation_review": "OPEN", "author_id": "KURPISHEV-IB", "work_family_id": "KLT-TOME-VI-CHEMISTRY", "locator": "word/document.xml body/p[1815] (one-based)", "quote_semantics": "SOURCE_TRANSCRIPTION", "source_verified": true, "source_status": "DOCX_PARAGRAPH_VERIFIED", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "paragraph_hash": "343d9d2eabeea782ae50fa574a8a9e74f10928bf37cf38281523984013526c1a", "D": { "scope": "TEXTUAL_CARRIER_ONLY", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "paragraph_index": 1814 }, "R": { "kind": "TEXTUAL_OCCURRENCE" }, "I": null, "U": null, "Dom": { "declared_keys": [ "CHEMISTRY_METHOD_PROTOCOL" ], "review_status": "OPEN" }, "domain_annotation_review": "OPEN", "truth_layer_promotion": 0, "proposed_domain_keys": [ "CHEMISTRY_METHOD_PROTOCOL" ], "domain_keys": [] }, { "occurrence_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1842", "work_id": "T6-RU-INTEGRATED-1.1", "paragraph_index": 1842, "quote": "Original EN preserved. Title: Current-corpus decision. Statement: The available real chemical corpus remains ABSTAIN at v0.8. Proof: No real source-bound preregistration, homogeneous Evidence-D class, strict matched-null, sealed hidden channel and independent EXT-RUN jointly exist in the frozen inputs. Since the strict gate is conjunctive, no real predictive candidate is constructed.", "claim_type": "CLAIM", "topic": "EXTERNAL_VALIDATION", "evidence_role": "SCOPE_BOUNDARY", "attribution_status": "UNKNOWN", "review_required": true, "interpretation_review": "OPEN", "author_id": "KURPISHEV-IB", "work_family_id": "KLT-TOME-VI-CHEMISTRY", "locator": "word/document.xml body/p[1843] (one-based)", "quote_semantics": "SOURCE_TRANSCRIPTION", "source_verified": true, "source_status": "DOCX_PARAGRAPH_VERIFIED", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "paragraph_hash": "b912d13c1a44aaa6e2143e7f7ac2e83b091703220818663f4033ff24fc4a53ef", "D": { "scope": "TEXTUAL_CARRIER_ONLY", "source_hash": "adecc02cabd08e192aa6e9fc8a8cc6f160a58dae4a44e9ad0cf7062c8f8f46cf", "paragraph_index": 1842 }, "R": { "kind": "TEXTUAL_OCCURRENCE" }, "I": null, "U": null, "Dom": { "declared_keys": [ "CHEMISTRY_METHOD_PROTOCOL" ], "review_status": "OPEN" }, "domain_annotation_review": "OPEN", "truth_layer_promotion": 0, "proposed_domain_keys": [ "CHEMISTRY_METHOD_PROTOCOL" ], "domain_keys": [] } ], "candidates": [ { "candidate_id": "CHEM-AR-001", "author_id": "KURPISHEV-IB", "title": "Граница программной и химической проверки", "member_occurrences": [ "CHEM-OCC-P0012", "CHEM-OCC-P0013" ], "status": "AUTHOR_REPER_CANDIDATE_REVIEW", "independent_work_families": [], "work_ids": [], "languages": [], "admitted_occurrence_ids": [], "withheld_occurrence_ids": [ "CHEM-OCC-P0012", "CHEM-OCC-P0013" ], "attribution_blockers": [ "CHEM-OCC-P0012", "CHEM-OCC-P0013" ], "overlapping_occurrence_ids": [], "criteria": { "build28_four_conditions": false, "partition_gate": true, "two_source_bound_families": false, "absence_scope": "NO_DIRECT_UNRESOLVED_IN_SUPPLIED_REGISTER_AND_SUPPORTED_RULE_FRAGMENT" }, "acp_order": [ "family_recurrence", "temporal_span", "attribution_coverage", "D_coverage", "Dom_coverage", "contradiction_load", "orphan_load" ], "ACP": { "family_recurrence": 0, "temporal_span": { "from_year": null, "to_year": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "attribution_coverage": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 2, "value": 0.0 }, "D_coverage": { "numerator": 2, "denominator": 2, "value": 1.0 }, "Dom_coverage": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 2, "value": 0.0 }, "contradiction_load": 0, "orphan_load": 0 }, "tension_review_count": 0, "truth_layer_promotion": 0, "open_gap_ids": [ "B28-G-0001", "B28-G-0002", "B28-G-0003", "B28-G-0004", "B28-G-0025" ], "open_gap_count": 5 }, { "candidate_id": "CHEM-AR-002", "author_id": "KURPISHEV-IB", "title": "Текстовые роли и химический репер", "member_occurrences": [ "CHEM-OCC-P1584", "CHEM-OCC-P1585" ], "status": "AUTHOR_REPER_CANDIDATE_REVIEW", "independent_work_families": [], "work_ids": [], "languages": [], "admitted_occurrence_ids": [], "withheld_occurrence_ids": [ "CHEM-OCC-P1584", "CHEM-OCC-P1585" ], "attribution_blockers": [ "CHEM-OCC-P1584", "CHEM-OCC-P1585" ], "overlapping_occurrence_ids": [], "criteria": { "build28_four_conditions": false, "partition_gate": true, "two_source_bound_families": false, "absence_scope": "NO_DIRECT_UNRESOLVED_IN_SUPPLIED_REGISTER_AND_SUPPORTED_RULE_FRAGMENT" }, "acp_order": [ "family_recurrence", "temporal_span", "attribution_coverage", "D_coverage", "Dom_coverage", "contradiction_load", "orphan_load" ], "ACP": { "family_recurrence": 0, "temporal_span": { "from_year": null, "to_year": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "attribution_coverage": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 2, "value": 0.0 }, "D_coverage": { "numerator": 2, "denominator": 2, "value": 1.0 }, "Dom_coverage": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 2, "value": 0.0 }, "contradiction_load": 0, "orphan_load": 0 }, "tension_review_count": 0, "truth_layer_promotion": 0, "open_gap_ids": [ "B28-G-0005", "B28-G-0006", "B28-G-0007", "B28-G-0008", "B28-G-0026" ], "open_gap_count": 5 }, { "candidate_id": "CHEM-AR-003", "author_id": "KURPISHEV-IB", "title": "Незакрытые ворота и ABSTAIN", "member_occurrences": [ "CHEM-OCC-P1590", "CHEM-OCC-P1591" ], "status": "AUTHOR_REPER_CANDIDATE_REVIEW", "independent_work_families": [], "work_ids": [], "languages": [], "admitted_occurrence_ids": [], "withheld_occurrence_ids": [ "CHEM-OCC-P1590", "CHEM-OCC-P1591" ], "attribution_blockers": [ "CHEM-OCC-P1590", "CHEM-OCC-P1591" ], "overlapping_occurrence_ids": [], "criteria": { "build28_four_conditions": false, "partition_gate": true, "two_source_bound_families": false, "absence_scope": "NO_DIRECT_UNRESOLVED_IN_SUPPLIED_REGISTER_AND_SUPPORTED_RULE_FRAGMENT" }, "acp_order": [ "family_recurrence", "temporal_span", "attribution_coverage", "D_coverage", "Dom_coverage", "contradiction_load", "orphan_load" ], "ACP": { "family_recurrence": 0, "temporal_span": { "from_year": null, "to_year": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "attribution_coverage": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 2, "value": 0.0 }, "D_coverage": { "numerator": 2, "denominator": 2, "value": 1.0 }, "Dom_coverage": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 2, "value": 0.0 }, "contradiction_load": 0, "orphan_load": 0 }, "tension_review_count": 0, "truth_layer_promotion": 0, "open_gap_ids": [ "B28-G-0009", "B28-G-0010", "B28-G-0011", "B28-G-0012", "B28-G-0027" ], "open_gap_count": 5 }, { "candidate_id": "CHEM-AR-004", "author_id": "KURPISHEV-IB", "title": "Выбор структуры репера", "member_occurrences": [ "CHEM-OCC-P1724", "CHEM-OCC-P1725" ], "status": "AUTHOR_REPER_CANDIDATE_REVIEW", "independent_work_families": [], "work_ids": [], "languages": [], "admitted_occurrence_ids": [], "withheld_occurrence_ids": [ "CHEM-OCC-P1724", "CHEM-OCC-P1725" ], "attribution_blockers": [ "CHEM-OCC-P1724", "CHEM-OCC-P1725" ], "overlapping_occurrence_ids": [], "criteria": { "build28_four_conditions": false, "partition_gate": true, "two_source_bound_families": false, "absence_scope": "NO_DIRECT_UNRESOLVED_IN_SUPPLIED_REGISTER_AND_SUPPORTED_RULE_FRAGMENT" }, "acp_order": [ "family_recurrence", "temporal_span", "attribution_coverage", "D_coverage", "Dom_coverage", "contradiction_load", "orphan_load" ], "ACP": { "family_recurrence": 0, "temporal_span": { "from_year": null, "to_year": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "attribution_coverage": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 2, "value": 0.0 }, "D_coverage": { "numerator": 2, "denominator": 2, "value": 1.0 }, "Dom_coverage": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 2, "value": 0.0 }, "contradiction_load": 0, "orphan_load": 0 }, "tension_review_count": 0, "truth_layer_promotion": 0, "open_gap_ids": [ "B28-G-0013", "B28-G-0014", "B28-G-0015", "B28-G-0016", "B28-G-0028" ], "open_gap_count": 5 }, { "candidate_id": "CHEM-AR-005", "author_id": "KURPISHEV-IB", "title": "Композиция с воздержанием", "member_occurrences": [ "CHEM-OCC-P1744", "CHEM-OCC-P1745" ], "status": "AUTHOR_REPER_CANDIDATE_REVIEW", "independent_work_families": [], "work_ids": [], "languages": [], "admitted_occurrence_ids": [], "withheld_occurrence_ids": [ "CHEM-OCC-P1744", "CHEM-OCC-P1745" ], "attribution_blockers": [ "CHEM-OCC-P1744", "CHEM-OCC-P1745" ], "overlapping_occurrence_ids": [], "criteria": { "build28_four_conditions": false, "partition_gate": true, "two_source_bound_families": false, "absence_scope": "NO_DIRECT_UNRESOLVED_IN_SUPPLIED_REGISTER_AND_SUPPORTED_RULE_FRAGMENT" }, "acp_order": [ "family_recurrence", "temporal_span", "attribution_coverage", "D_coverage", "Dom_coverage", "contradiction_load", "orphan_load" ], "ACP": { "family_recurrence": 0, "temporal_span": { "from_year": null, "to_year": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "attribution_coverage": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 2, "value": 0.0 }, "D_coverage": { "numerator": 2, "denominator": 2, "value": 1.0 }, "Dom_coverage": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 2, "value": 0.0 }, "contradiction_load": 0, "orphan_load": 0 }, "tension_review_count": 0, "truth_layer_promotion": 0, "open_gap_ids": [ "B28-G-0017", "B28-G-0018", "B28-G-0019", "B28-G-0020", "B28-G-0029" ], "open_gap_count": 5 }, { "candidate_id": "CHEM-AR-006", "author_id": "KURPISHEV-IB", "title": "Независимая внешняя проверка", "member_occurrences": [ "CHEM-OCC-P1814", "CHEM-OCC-P1842" ], "status": "AUTHOR_REPER_CANDIDATE_REVIEW", "independent_work_families": [], "work_ids": [], "languages": [], "admitted_occurrence_ids": [], "withheld_occurrence_ids": [ "CHEM-OCC-P1814", "CHEM-OCC-P1842" ], "attribution_blockers": [ "CHEM-OCC-P1814", "CHEM-OCC-P1842" ], "overlapping_occurrence_ids": [], "criteria": { "build28_four_conditions": false, "partition_gate": true, "two_source_bound_families": false, "absence_scope": "NO_DIRECT_UNRESOLVED_IN_SUPPLIED_REGISTER_AND_SUPPORTED_RULE_FRAGMENT" }, "acp_order": [ "family_recurrence", "temporal_span", "attribution_coverage", "D_coverage", "Dom_coverage", "contradiction_load", "orphan_load" ], "ACP": { "family_recurrence": 0, "temporal_span": { "from_year": null, "to_year": null, "precision": "YEAR" }, "attribution_coverage": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 2, "value": 0.0 }, "D_coverage": { "numerator": 2, "denominator": 2, "value": 1.0 }, "Dom_coverage": { "numerator": 0, "denominator": 2, "value": 0.0 }, "contradiction_load": 0, "orphan_load": 0 }, "tension_review_count": 0, "truth_layer_promotion": 0, "open_gap_ids": [ "B28-G-0021", "B28-G-0022", "B28-G-0023", "B28-G-0024", "B28-G-0030" ], "open_gap_count": 5 } ], "edges": [], "conflicts": [], "truth_layer_promotion": 0, "gaps": [ { "gap_id": "B28-G-0001", "gap_type": "GAP-ATTRIBUTION", "level": "OCCURRENCE", "ref_id": "CHEM-OCC-P0012", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "Authorial voice or mediation needs explicit review", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0002", "gap_type": "GAP-DOM", "level": "OCCURRENCE", "ref_id": "CHEM-OCC-P0012", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "No typed domain annotation bound to this occurrence's source page", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0003", "gap_type": "GAP-ATTRIBUTION", "level": "OCCURRENCE", "ref_id": "CHEM-OCC-P0013", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "Authorial voice or mediation needs explicit review", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0004", "gap_type": "GAP-DOM", "level": "OCCURRENCE", "ref_id": "CHEM-OCC-P0013", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "No typed domain annotation bound to this occurrence's source page", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0005", "gap_type": "GAP-ATTRIBUTION", "level": "OCCURRENCE", "ref_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1584", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "Authorial voice or mediation needs explicit review", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0006", "gap_type": "GAP-DOM", "level": "OCCURRENCE", "ref_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1584", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "No typed domain annotation bound to this occurrence's source page", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0007", "gap_type": "GAP-ATTRIBUTION", "level": "OCCURRENCE", "ref_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1585", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "Authorial voice or mediation needs explicit review", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0008", "gap_type": "GAP-DOM", "level": "OCCURRENCE", "ref_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1585", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "No typed domain annotation bound to this occurrence's source page", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0009", "gap_type": "GAP-ATTRIBUTION", "level": "OCCURRENCE", "ref_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1590", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "Authorial voice or mediation needs explicit review", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0010", "gap_type": "GAP-DOM", "level": "OCCURRENCE", "ref_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1590", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "No typed domain annotation bound to this occurrence's source page", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0011", "gap_type": "GAP-ATTRIBUTION", "level": "OCCURRENCE", "ref_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1591", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "Authorial voice or mediation needs explicit review", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0012", "gap_type": "GAP-DOM", "level": "OCCURRENCE", "ref_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1591", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "No typed domain annotation bound to this occurrence's source page", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0013", "gap_type": "GAP-ATTRIBUTION", "level": "OCCURRENCE", "ref_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1724", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "Authorial voice or mediation needs explicit review", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0014", "gap_type": "GAP-DOM", "level": "OCCURRENCE", "ref_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1724", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "No typed domain annotation bound to this occurrence's source page", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0015", "gap_type": "GAP-ATTRIBUTION", "level": "OCCURRENCE", "ref_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1725", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "Authorial voice or mediation needs explicit review", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0016", "gap_type": "GAP-DOM", "level": "OCCURRENCE", "ref_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1725", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "No typed domain annotation bound to this occurrence's source page", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0017", "gap_type": "GAP-ATTRIBUTION", "level": "OCCURRENCE", "ref_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1744", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "Authorial voice or mediation needs explicit review", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0018", "gap_type": "GAP-DOM", "level": "OCCURRENCE", "ref_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1744", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "No typed domain annotation bound to this occurrence's source page", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0019", "gap_type": "GAP-ATTRIBUTION", "level": "OCCURRENCE", "ref_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1745", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "Authorial voice or mediation needs explicit review", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0020", "gap_type": "GAP-DOM", "level": "OCCURRENCE", "ref_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1745", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "No typed domain annotation bound to this occurrence's source page", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0021", "gap_type": "GAP-ATTRIBUTION", "level": "OCCURRENCE", "ref_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1814", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "Authorial voice or mediation needs explicit review", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0022", "gap_type": "GAP-DOM", "level": "OCCURRENCE", "ref_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1814", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "No typed domain annotation bound to this occurrence's source page", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0023", "gap_type": "GAP-ATTRIBUTION", "level": "OCCURRENCE", "ref_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1842", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "Authorial voice or mediation needs explicit review", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0024", "gap_type": "GAP-DOM", "level": "OCCURRENCE", "ref_id": "CHEM-OCC-P1842", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "No typed domain annotation bound to this occurrence's source page", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0025", "gap_type": "SINGLE-WORK-PERIPHERAL", "level": "CANDIDATE", "ref_id": "CHEM-AR-001", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "Fewer than two admitted independent work families", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0026", "gap_type": "SINGLE-WORK-PERIPHERAL", "level": "CANDIDATE", "ref_id": "CHEM-AR-002", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "Fewer than two admitted independent work families", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0027", "gap_type": "SINGLE-WORK-PERIPHERAL", "level": "CANDIDATE", "ref_id": "CHEM-AR-003", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "Fewer than two admitted independent work families", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0028", "gap_type": "SINGLE-WORK-PERIPHERAL", "level": "CANDIDATE", "ref_id": "CHEM-AR-004", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "Fewer than two admitted independent work families", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0029", "gap_type": "SINGLE-WORK-PERIPHERAL", "level": "CANDIDATE", "ref_id": "CHEM-AR-005", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "Fewer than two admitted independent work families", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, { "gap_id": "B28-G-0030", "gap_type": "SINGLE-WORK-PERIPHERAL", "level": "CANDIDATE", "ref_id": "CHEM-AR-006", "status": "OPEN", "reason": "Fewer than two admitted independent work families", "detail": null, "truth_layer_promotion": 0 } ], "overlapping_memberships": {}, "logical_scan": { "pair_count": 0, "verdict_counts": {}, "direct_pairs": [], "full_logical_consistency": "NOT_ESTABLISHED", "engine_scope": "REVIEWED_GROUND_LITERALS_ONLY", "truth_layer_promotion": 0 }, "summary": { "authors": 1, "works": 1, "work_families": 1, "occurrences": 12, "membership_links": 12, "candidates": 6, "core_candidates": 0, "authorial_admitted_occurrences": 0, "authorial_source_bound_occurrences": 0, "attribution_review_occurrences": 12, "source_bound_occurrences": 12, "exact_line_bound_occurrences": 0, "overlapping_occurrences": 0, "affected_overlap_candidates": 0, "mapped_edges": 0, "legacy_edges": 0, "tension_cases": 0, "direct_pairs": 0, "new_gap_count": 30, "gap_type_counts": { "GAP-ATTRIBUTION": 12, "GAP-DOM": 12, "SINGLE-WORK-PERIPHERAL": 6 }, "full_work_byte_freeze_count": 1, "science_status": "ABSTAIN", "independent_semantic_review": "NOT_RUN", "truth_layer_promotion": 0 } }, "chemical_links": [ { "candidate_id": "CHEM-AR-001", "status": "TEXTUAL_REPER_ONLY", "support_occurrence_ids": [], "scope_boundary_occurrence_ids": [ "CHEM-OCC-P0012", "CHEM-OCC-P0013" ], "material_id": null, "observation_id": null, "target_hash": null, "chemical_link": "NOT_ESTABLISHED", "chemical_observations_created": 0, "blockers": [ "ATTRIBUTION_REVIEW_OPEN", "SEMANTIC_DOMAIN_REVIEW_OPEN", "MATERIAL_STRUCTURE_PHASE_LINK_MISSING", "PROPERTY_METHOD_UNIT_STATE_LINK_MISSING", "INDEPENDENT_VALIDATION_NOT_RUN" ] }, { "candidate_id": "CHEM-AR-002", "status": "TEXTUAL_REPER_ONLY", "support_occurrence_ids": [], "scope_boundary_occurrence_ids": [ "CHEM-OCC-P1584", "CHEM-OCC-P1585" ], "material_id": null, "observation_id": null, "target_hash": null, "chemical_link": "NOT_ESTABLISHED", "chemical_observations_created": 0, "blockers": [ "ATTRIBUTION_REVIEW_OPEN", "SEMANTIC_DOMAIN_REVIEW_OPEN", "MATERIAL_STRUCTURE_PHASE_LINK_MISSING", "PROPERTY_METHOD_UNIT_STATE_LINK_MISSING", "INDEPENDENT_VALIDATION_NOT_RUN" ] }, { "candidate_id": "CHEM-AR-003", "status": "TEXTUAL_REPER_ONLY", "support_occurrence_ids": [ "CHEM-OCC-P1590", "CHEM-OCC-P1591" ], "scope_boundary_occurrence_ids": [], "material_id": null, "observation_id": null, "target_hash": null, "chemical_link": "NOT_ESTABLISHED", "chemical_observations_created": 0, "blockers": [ "ATTRIBUTION_REVIEW_OPEN", "SEMANTIC_DOMAIN_REVIEW_OPEN", "MATERIAL_STRUCTURE_PHASE_LINK_MISSING", "PROPERTY_METHOD_UNIT_STATE_LINK_MISSING", "INDEPENDENT_VALIDATION_NOT_RUN" ] }, { "candidate_id": "CHEM-AR-004", "status": "TEXTUAL_REPER_ONLY", "support_occurrence_ids": [], "scope_boundary_occurrence_ids": [ "CHEM-OCC-P1724", "CHEM-OCC-P1725" ], "material_id": null, "observation_id": null, "target_hash": null, "chemical_link": "NOT_ESTABLISHED", "chemical_observations_created": 0, "blockers": [ "ATTRIBUTION_REVIEW_OPEN", "SEMANTIC_DOMAIN_REVIEW_OPEN", "MATERIAL_STRUCTURE_PHASE_LINK_MISSING", "PROPERTY_METHOD_UNIT_STATE_LINK_MISSING", "INDEPENDENT_VALIDATION_NOT_RUN" ] }, { "candidate_id": "CHEM-AR-005", "status": "TEXTUAL_REPER_ONLY", "support_occurrence_ids": [ "CHEM-OCC-P1744", "CHEM-OCC-P1745" ], "scope_boundary_occurrence_ids": [], "material_id": null, "observation_id": null, "target_hash": null, "chemical_link": "NOT_ESTABLISHED", "chemical_observations_created": 0, "blockers": [ "ATTRIBUTION_REVIEW_OPEN", "SEMANTIC_DOMAIN_REVIEW_OPEN", "MATERIAL_STRUCTURE_PHASE_LINK_MISSING", "PROPERTY_METHOD_UNIT_STATE_LINK_MISSING", "INDEPENDENT_VALIDATION_NOT_RUN" ] }, { "candidate_id": "CHEM-AR-006", "status": "TEXTUAL_REPER_ONLY", "support_occurrence_ids": [], "scope_boundary_occurrence_ids": [ "CHEM-OCC-P1814", "CHEM-OCC-P1842" ], "material_id": null, "observation_id": null, "target_hash": null, "chemical_link": "NOT_ESTABLISHED", "chemical_observations_created": 0, "blockers": [ "ATTRIBUTION_REVIEW_OPEN", "SEMANTIC_DOMAIN_REVIEW_OPEN", "MATERIAL_STRUCTURE_PHASE_LINK_MISSING", "PROPERTY_METHOD_UNIT_STATE_LINK_MISSING", "INDEPENDENT_VALIDATION_NOT_RUN" ] } ], "scope": "12_PARAGRAPH_PILOT", "semantics": { "source_verification": "EXACT_DOCX_PARAGRAPHS", "source_verification_is_attribution_review": false, "support_and_scope_roles": "EDITORIAL_PROPOSALS_NOT_INFERENCE_PREMISES", "missing_relations_are_contradictions": false, "full_tome_analysis": "NOT_RUN" }, "status_firewall": { "science": "ABSTAIN", "DHC_chem": "OPEN-NOT-CONFIRMED", "EXT-RUN": "NOT_RUN", "truth_layer_promotion": 0, "T6-RA5": "NOT_ISSUED", "axiom_promotion": "DISABLED" }, "chemical_observations_created": 0, "source_files_mutated": 0, "logical_rule_import_from_kant": "NONE", "report_hash": "e24e1773f9c929237d6736c0d0d0df01eaab17ad71c4d6203d1c772e93a4814e" }